Angioplasty Live! Last
month saw the publication of a joint statement on: "The
Use of Live Case Demonstrations at Cardiology Meetings" --
from
the SCAI, ACC, HRS, ESC, SOLACI et al. The subject at hand was
the proper and ethical
use
of live angioplasty cases that were being broadcast around the
world as a physician training tool.
The photo above shows Dr. Andreas Gruentzig in his catheterization
lab during a live course at Emory Hospital in Atlanta, where
he conducted a number of broadcasts in the early 1980's. His purpose
was to train cardiologists in this radical new procedure that he
had invented in 1977: balloon angioplasty.
Gruentzig was adamant that physicians needed to be well-trained and
cautious when beginning
to do these new types of procedures. Because he knew that unbridled
expansion of his technique would result
in complications and poor outcomes -- and that would stifle the development
of this minimally invasive treatment for coronary artery disease.
The years intervening have changed both the purpose and
presentation of these live courses considerably. 1978 saw the first
of these courses, when Gruentzig, then at University Hospital
in Zurich, could not accomodate all the physicians who wanted to
learn his technique via visits to his cath lab.
So
only months after he had invented the procedure, he invited 28
physicians to gather in the auditorium of the hospital and watch
him perform angioplasty on seven patients via a small
closed-circuit TV monitor (pictured on right). At that point Gruentzig
had only done 27 angioplasties...period! That event, and the subsequent
live courses that he did in Zurich
and then in Atlanta were the genesis of
a whole new specialty, interventional cardiology, and a whole new
type of therapy for
patients -- opening blockages, delivering heart valves, stopping
heart attacks as they are occurring(!) -- all without surgery,
without opening the chest, without using a heart-lung machine --
all done by inserting a catheter in the groin or arm artery.
At last month's TCT meeting
in Washington, 10,000 attendees watched more than 100 hours of
live cases, beamed in from Germany, France and 17 other international
sites -- and in high definition on a 150' screen!
(photo above from PSAV
Presentation Services.) Quite a change in a little over three decades.
So the regulatory agencies and professional
societies have become concerned that live courses, which
have become the cornerstone of many highly-attended cardiology
meetings, be done in an ethical, safe and rational manner; that
they do not
become merely showcases for new equipment, whose manufacturers
have contributed to the bottom line of the meeting; that the safety
and privacy of the patients involved are protected. These are valid
concerns and the
joint statement is a good touchstone -- all would be welcomed by
Andreas Gruentzig.
But the very early angioplasty courses,
many of which I had the honor of producing and directing, were
a bit different than today. As Dr. Richard Myler, who performed
the first angioplasty in the U.S. (simultaneously with Dr. Simon
Stertzer) says in the video below:
"No one, to my knowledge,
had ever taught a medical technique in front of a live
audience when we ourselves were just infants in the technique
itself. We were learning it, and there were people in the audience
watching
us do it, live!"
I
created the video below to accompany a discussion of this topic
during the 2009 CRT meeting in Washington,
as part
of the FDA Workshop. It gives a
taste of
what these early
courses were like -- where the patients, instead of having their
privacy protected, sat up proudly after the successful procedure
and gladly waved with a smile to the audience of cardiologists,
a group that would go on to make angioplasty the gold standard
for the treatment of heart attacks.
(Disclosures: the creation of the above video
was supported by an unrestricted educational grant from Abbott
Vascular. Speaking in the video are John E. Abele, co-founder
of Boston Scientific, Maria Schlumpf, Gruentzig's assistant,
Dr. Spencer B. King, III, Dr.
Richard K. Myler, Dr. Gary S. Roubin and Dr.
Martin B. Leon. Music by Nell Shaw Cohen.)