BASKET-LATE
Study Shows Higher Rate of
Cardiac Death and Heart Attack for
Drug-Eluting Stents vs. Bare Metal
Stents
March
14, 2006 --
This small study titled BASKET-LATE (Basel Stent Cost-effectiveness
Trial—Late
Thrombotic Events) was almost overlooked when presented on the final day of
the American College of Cardiology annual meeting, but the conclusion of the
study mirrors a concern that we here at Angioplasty.Org have been writing about
-- the need for continued long term antiplatelet therapy after drug-eluting
stents. Now, Dr. Matthias E. Pfisterer of University Hospital in Basel, Switzerland,
has concluded that there is concern for patients with drug-eluting stents for
a year or more AFTER stopping the recommended clopidogrel (Plavix) and aspirin
therapy.
The study tracked over 800 patients.
Two-thirds had received drug-eluting stents, the remaining third
got a bare metal stent. Clopidogrel (Plavix) was
stopped at 6 months, as per current minimum recommendations. What the study
revealed was that in the period after clopidogrel was stopped, thrombosis-related
events (which are very serious) occurred twice as often in the drug-eluting
stent patients, and that these events carried "4 times higher risk of
cardiac death/MI vs non-thrombosis-related events". The worrisome statistic
was that these increased thrombosis-related events were still occurring a year
after stopping antiplatelet therapy. The authors concluded that "real-world
DES use in 100 patients avoids 5 target vessel revascularization events at
6 months but leads to 3.3 late deaths or MI."
Dr. William O'Neill of William
Beaumont Medical Center in Michigan, commented to the cardiologists in
the audience:
"The real question that
clinicians are going to have is: are you really trading late
restenosis,
which is not
a
health hazard, for death
or reinfarction? That's obviously a very important and worrisome
trade-off."
On
theheart.org, Drs. Eric Topol and Rob Califf discuss the trial as well,
and both agree on the concern. Dr. Califf states, "In my practice,
if you get a drug-eluting stent, you're going to be on clopidogrel for
life until
more data come in."
(Disclaimer: external
links to news, press releases and other timely information
sources are provided as a service by Angioplasty.Org, which
is not responsible for the content found on any external
sites. Items marked with a ($$) indicate that the external
site normally restricts viewing to paid subscribers. Other
sites may require free registration.
send comments & suggestions
to "info at angioplasty dot org"
Read our Privacy statement.
Angioplasty.Org is an editorially independent informational health
site
which has received unrestricted educational grants from Medtronic plc,
TCROSS NEWS, Toshiba
America
Medical Systems, Volcano
Corporation, Terumo
Medical Corporation
Cardium Therapeutics, Inc. and Lenox Hill Heart and Vascular Institute of NY