BASKET-LATE
Study Shows Higher Rate of
Cardiac Death and Heart Attack for
Drug-Eluting Stents vs. Bare Metal
Stents
March
14, 2006 --
This small study titled BASKET-LATE (Basel Stent Cost-effectiveness
Trial—Late
Thrombotic Events) was almost overlooked when presented on the final day of
the American College of Cardiology annual meeting, but the conclusion of the
study mirrors a concern that we here at Angioplasty.Org have been writing about
-- the need for continued long term antiplatelet therapy after drug-eluting
stents. Now, Dr. Matthias E. Pfisterer of University Hospital in Basel, Switzerland,
has concluded that there is concern for patients with drug-eluting stents for
a year or more AFTER stopping the recommended clopidogrel (Plavix) and aspirin
therapy.
The study tracked over 800 patients.
Two-thirds had received drug-eluting stents, the remaining third
got a bare metal stent. Clopidogrel (Plavix) was
stopped at 6 months, as per current minimum recommendations. What the study
revealed was that in the period after clopidogrel was stopped, thrombosis-related
events (which are very serious) occurred twice as often in the drug-eluting
stent patients, and that these events carried "4 times higher risk of
cardiac death/MI vs non-thrombosis-related events". The worrisome statistic
was that these increased thrombosis-related events were still occurring a year
after stopping antiplatelet therapy. The authors concluded that "real-world
DES use in 100 patients avoids 5 target vessel revascularization events at
6 months but leads to 3.3 late deaths or MI."
Dr. William O'Neill of William
Beaumont Medical Center in Michigan, commented to the cardiologists in
the audience:
"The real question that
clinicians are going to have is: are you really trading late
restenosis,
which is not
a
health hazard, for death
or reinfarction? That's obviously a very important and worrisome
trade-off."
On
theheart.org, Drs. Eric Topol and Rob Califf discuss the trial as well,
and both agree on the concern. Dr. Califf states, "In my practice,
if you get a drug-eluting stent, you're going to be on clopidogrel for
life until
more data come in."
(Disclaimer: external
links to news, press releases and other timely information
sources are provided as a service by Angioplasty.Org, which
is not responsible for the content found on any external
sites. Items marked with a ($$) indicate that the external
site normally restricts viewing to paid subscribers. Other
sites may require free registration.