Current Postings on This Page (4):
There is alot of misinformation circulated about
healthcare let's hope
for the best for Obama's Administration.
John P., Randolph, New Jersey, USA, May 5, 2010
James from Kansas -- thanks for the query.
The opthamologist you mentioned was Dr. Zane F. Pollard, an eye doctor
in Atlanta,
Georgia. His article, "Obamacare
and Me" appeared in "The American Thinker", a conservative
web site that has published many articles critical of Obama. Those on the
left have characterized it as "one of those hard-edged,
right-wing web sites that specializes in flinging filth (Huffington
Post). But to set aside partisan politics and answer your question.
Dr. Pollard writes of Obama's Health Reform Bill:
For those of you who are over 65, this bill in its present
form might be lethal for you. People in England over 59 cannot receive
stents for their coronary arteries. The government wants to mimic the British
plan.
This and many other assertions about the British system
have been emphatically denied by Britain's National Health
Service in several places -- one in a letter
written
by Secretary
Andy
Burnham to
Dr. Hisham
Rana, whose blog reproduced the letter
in full. Here's the part about stents:
Question 2: In England, anyone over 59
years of age can’t
receive heart repairs, stents or bypass because it is not covered
as being too
expensive and not needed—an anonymously authored, but widely circulated,
email, largely sent to older voters. The Department of Health
can confirm that this statement is not true. Access to treatment should
be offered
on the basis of clinical need. You may be interested to know that a
national audit report on cardiac surgery, which has just been published
shows
that, in the United Kingdom, 20% of all cardiac surgery patients are
over 75
years old.
There has been much misinformation circulated about what
health care under the Obama Plan would look like, for example, "death panels",
etc. What the U.S. plan ultimately is going to be is an unknown
at present, but
if
you look
at some
of the topics on this Forum, like "Financial
Assistance for Plavix", you will see
a number of U.S. citizens not being able to get a drug critical to keeping
their stents open. On one hand the U.S. FDA recommends that patients with
drug-eluting stents be given Plavix for at least a year, but how many patients
who get a drug-eluting stent and get it paid for by private insurance are
then denied the year of Plavix. They stop taking it and increase their
risk of heart
attack
and death. Certainly this doesn't work either.
Angioplasty.Org Staff, Angioplasty.Org, August 17, 2009
An American pediatric ophthalmologist has
recently written a piece opposing government organized heath care in
the U.S. Among his assertions
is people over age 59 are denied implanting of stents. This seems unlikely
to me and I would like to debunk it if it isn't true. Can anyone help?
General policy would be best but hearing from individuals would be useful
too.Many
thanks.
James Guglielmino, Mission, Kansas, USA, August 16, 2009
I returned home today after a six night stay
in an ICU ward following a heart attack (I am 49, do not smoke or drink,
am fit but have a family history of heart disease). I was transferred to
a special heart unit in a larger urban hospital where I underwent an angiogram
and received 4 stents in my heart. I was then returned back to my home
town hospital where I was observed for a further night prior to my release.
Because of my unusual circumstances I am now being transferred to the Cardiologist
who performed the angioplasty for follow ups and recuperation. All the
time I received excellent, prompt treatment from every party concerned
in my care (Paramedics,ER staff, ICU staff, Cardio unit, etc)...and the
cost to me.....nothing, you see I live in Canada where we have universal
health care (granted, we pay $164 per month health contribution as a family)
so I shake my head in dismay at the debate going on down south. Whenever
we have needed the health system here at has been available (last year
my wife was confirmed with breast cancer and her comprehensive treatment
was fantastic) -- it's not perfect, but I would not wish to swap it for
the for the US system.
Jeff, BC, Canada, August 12, 2009
|